Climate change

Managing Acidity: Vineyard First, Cellar Second

What a winemaker can legally and practically do about acidity after the fruit is in, and why most cool climate producers would rather solve it in the vineyard.

Cool Climate Wine Summit · · 3 questions to check yourself

Total acidity, pH and the balance between tartaric and malic acid all move during ripening, fermentation and ageing. A winemaker has a handful of tools, all regulated, and none of them fully replaces getting it right at harvest.

The options

  • Blocking malolactic fermentation, which keeps whatever malic acid remains. Standard for cool climate whites and entirely uncontroversial.
  • Tartaric acidification, adding tartaric acid to the must or wine. Permitted within limits in EU law and more common in warm vintages than labels suggest.
  • Blending, using an early-picked parcel with high acidity to lift the rest.
  • Deacidification with calcium carbonate or potassium bicarbonate, which is the opposite problem and was routine in cold German vintages.
  • Cold stabilisation, which removes tartrate crystals and lowers acidity slightly as a side effect.
Q1 Which acidity tool is used in the majority of cool climate white wine?
It is a decision not to do something rather than an addition, which is why almost every producer, including low intervention ones, uses it.

pH versus total acidity

These move together but are not the same. Total acidity is how much acid is present. pH is how strongly the wine is buffered, and it is affected by potassium levels as well as by acid.

pH is the more important number for stability: free sulphur dioxide is far more effective at low pH, so a high pH wine needs more sulphur to achieve the same protection. That is one reason the low sulphur movement cares so much about picking dates.

Q2 Why does pH matter more than total acidity for wine stability?
A wine can have respectable total acidity and a pH high enough to need considerably more sulphur, which is exactly the situation low intervention producers want to avoid.

The low intervention view

Producers working with minimal additions mostly refuse acidification and solve the problem by picking. The cost is a narrower window and more risk, and the benefit is that the acidity is structural rather than added.

Kamil Barczentewicz describes the objective of that approach in terms that apply directly here: nothing funky, nothing crazy, just a really pure product.

“Nothing funky, nothing crazy, nothing like natural wine. Just a really, really pure product.”

Kamil Barczentewicz · read the interview
Q3 What is the trade-off of refusing acidification?
Everything has to be decided in the vineyard, which raises the stakes on a single harvest decision.

Sources

  1. Interview: Kamil Barczentewicz, Cool Climate Wine Summit Recorded by us. Quoted from the transcript.
  2. OIV, International Code of Oenological Practices, OIV
  3. European Commission, wine sector, European Commission
How this page was made. The background is standard viticultural reference material. The quotations come from interviews the Cool Climate Wine Summit recorded itself, and each one links to the full conversation. The text is drafted with AI assistance from those transcripts and then read, corrected and approved by a human editor before it is published. All interviews.
Newsletter

More of this, every few weeks

New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.

I am a