Climate change

Botrytis: Noble Rot or Lost Crop

The same organism makes Trockenbeerenauslese and ruins a harvest. What separates noble rot from grey rot, and why warm autumns have made the distinction harder to hold.

Cool Climate Wine Summit · · 3 questions to check yourself

Botrytis cinerea is a single fungus with two completely different outcomes. As noble rot it concentrates sugar and acid in healthy ripe fruit and produces the great sweet wines of Germany, Sauternes and Tokaj. As grey rot it destroys the crop.

The difference is not the organism. It is the condition of the fruit it lands on and the weather that follows.

What noble rot requires

  • Fully ripe, undamaged fruit with intact skins.
  • Misty humid mornings, which let the fungus establish.
  • Dry breezy afternoons, which dehydrate the berry rather than letting the infection run.
  • That alternation sustained over weeks, not days.
  • Selective hand picking, berry by berry, several times through the same parcel.

River valleys provide the mist and the afternoon breeze, which is why the classic botrytis regions sit on water: the Mosel, the Rheingau, the Loire, the Ciron at Sauternes.

Q1 What weather pattern produces noble rot rather than grey rot?
The alternation is everything. Without the drying phase the same fungus simply rots the fruit.

What grey rot does

On damaged or unripe fruit, or in continuous damp, botrytis spreads laterally through the bunch, breaks down the skins and lets bacteria and sour rot in behind it. The result is volatile acidity, brown pigments and an enzyme, laccase, that oxidises the wine and is difficult to remove.

This is why hail is followed immediately by a spray. Every split berry is an entry point, and in warm humid weather the infection follows within days.

Q2 Why is laccase a particular problem in rot-affected fruit?
It survives into the cellar and keeps working there, which is why rot-affected fruit is sorted out rather than treated.

Warm autumns

The traditional botrytis window depended on a long cool autumn in which healthy fruit could hang into November. A warmer autumn accelerates everything, so the fruit is riper earlier and the fungus, when it arrives, works faster and less selectively.

That is part of why the great sweet wines have become rarer and more expensive. Kirsten in Piesport makes their JoGo only in years when the fruit justifies it, which is now the normal way these wines are planned.

Q3 Why have classic botrytis sweet wines become rarer?
Demand has fallen too, but the physical window itself has narrowed, which is why estates now declare these wines only in suitable years.

Sources

  1. Deutsches Weininstitut, DWI
  2. Julius Kühn-Institut, JKI
How this page was made. The background is standard viticultural reference material. The quotations come from interviews the Cool Climate Wine Summit recorded itself, and each one links to the full conversation. The text is drafted with AI assistance from those transcripts and then read, corrected and approved by a human editor before it is published. All interviews.
Newsletter

More of this, every few weeks

New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.

I am a