Viticulture

Erosion: What Heavy Rain Does to a Bare Slope

A cloudburst on a bare slope takes the topsoil to the bottom of the hill in an afternoon. Growers can now film the difference between their own vineyard and their neighbour's, and several have.

Cool Climate Wine Summit · · 3 questions to check yourself

Erosion in a vineyard is not a slow process. It happens in single events: a summer thunderstorm dropping 40 millimetres in twenty minutes onto a slope whose soil cannot absorb it that fast. The water runs, and it takes the finest and most fertile fraction of the soil with it.

On a steep site the loss is visible the same day, as a gully, a fan of soil across the track, and a road full of mud at the bottom of the hill.

The comparison growers film

Stephan Steinmetz on the Upper Mosel recorded a heavy rainfall event walking past three neighbouring vineyards. On the conventional plot the water could not get in and ran straight down the road. On the organic neighbour, less. On his own, which sits highest and should therefore have shed the most, essentially none, because the ground could take it.

Volker Benzinger in the Pfalz reports the other side of the same coin: after the rainfall that caused the Ahr flood they had 240 litres in two days, and because the rows were green they could get back in with the sprayer the following day.

“We have lived here for millions of years and we have only been treating our food for 120 years. We cannot go on like that.”

Stephan Steinmetz · read the interview
Q1 Why did the highest vineyard shed the least water in that comparison?
Position on the slope should make the top plot worst. It was the best because infiltration, not gradient, decides what runs off.

What actually holds a slope

  • Living roots, which bind the surface. This is the largest single factor.
  • Organic matter, which builds the crumb structure that lets water in.
  • Mulch and rolled cover, which break the impact of raindrops before they seal the surface.
  • Terraces and walls, which shorten the run and slow the water.
  • Cross-slope rather than up-and-down rows, where the machinery allows it.

Thomas Philipps on the Mittelrhein puts the mechanism in one line: the small roots hold the ground, and the humus behind them works like a sponge, so that rain after a dry spell is held and released slowly.

Q2 What breaks the impact of raindrops and stops the soil surface sealing?
A sealed surface sheds water however good the soil below is. Something has to take the impact, which is what the mulch layer does.

It still happens

None of this makes a vineyard proof against a serious event. Benedikt Nilles on the Mosel pointed out a visible gap in his steepest parcel where heavy rain had run straight down the hill, and described it as a situation to live with.

Which is the accurate framing. Soil work changes the frequency and the severity, not the physics of a 70 per cent slope in a cloudburst.

Q3 What does good soil management achieve against erosion?
The difference between plots in a downpour is large and visible. It is not the same as immunity, and the growers concerned do not claim it is.

Sources

  1. Interview: Stephan Steinmetz, Cool Climate Wine Summit Recorded by us. Quoted from the transcript.
  2. ECOVIN, Federal Association of Organic Viticulture, ECOVIN
  3. Deutsches Weininstitut, DWI
How this page was made. The background is standard viticultural reference material. The quotations come from interviews the Cool Climate Wine Summit recorded itself, and each one links to the full conversation. The text is drafted with AI assistance from those transcripts and then read, corrected and approved by a human editor before it is published. All interviews.
Newsletter

More of this, every few weeks

New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.

I am a