Climate change

Hail: The Loss You Cannot Plan For

Ten minutes that can remove a crop and damage the following year as well. What hail does to a vine and the very short list of things that help.

Cool Climate Wine Summit · · 3 questions to check yourself

Hail is the most local of the weather risks. It follows narrow corridors, so one grower loses everything and a neighbour two kilometres away loses nothing, and it arrives with almost no warning.

During our interview at Les Vins Porret in Neuchâtel a hailstorm came down off the Jura and the conversation moved indoors, which is a fair illustration of how quickly it happens.

What it damages

  • The crop, directly: split berries, which then rot.
  • Leaves, which reduces the vine's ability to ripen whatever survives.
  • Shoots and green wood, which carries into the following year because next season's buds sit on this season's canes.
  • The trunk and cordon in severe cases, which can take years to recover.

That third point is the one people underestimate. A bad hailstorm is not a one-vintage event. Nestor Kościański lost around 80 per cent of one crop to frost and then had hail in July of the same year, which is the combination that makes a season unrecoverable.

Q1 Why can hail damage affect the following vintage?
Damage to green wood removes the wood next year's crop would have come from, which is why a single storm can cost two harvests.

What helps

Hail netting works and is used in high value regions, at considerable cost and with an effect on the canopy microclimate. Cloud seeding is used at regional level in parts of France, Italy and Austria, and its effectiveness is disputed.

Insurance is the realistic answer for a commercial estate, and is heavily subsidised in several EU countries. For a grower with two hectares and direct sales, the premium often makes no sense.

Q2 What is the most widely used practical response to hail risk?
Netting is expensive and only used in the highest value vineyards. Most growers transfer the risk rather than trying to prevent it.

Afterwards

The immediate priority is disease. Split berries and torn leaves are open wounds, and in warm humid weather sour rot and botrytis follow within days. A protective spray goes on as soon as the vineyard can be entered.

Then the decision about whether to harvest at all. Sorting damaged fruit is slow, and the resulting wine is rarely worth the labour, which is why growers often drop the crop and concentrate on getting the vine into winter in good condition.

Q3 What is the immediate risk after a hailstorm?
Every wound is an entry point. In warm humid weather the infection follows within days, which is why spraying is urgent.

Sources

  1. Julius Kühn-Institut, JKI
  2. Deutsches Weininstitut, DWI
How this page was made. The background is standard viticultural reference material. The quotations come from interviews the Cool Climate Wine Summit recorded itself, and each one links to the full conversation. The text is drafted with AI assistance from those transcripts and then read, corrected and approved by a human editor before it is published. All interviews.
Newsletter

More of this, every few weeks

New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.

I am a