Viticulture

Slate: Blue, Grey and Red, and What Each One Tastes Like

Blue, grey and red slate all occur on the Mosel, often within a few hundred metres, and growers there will tell you each one tastes different. Here is what they say, and what the stone actually does.

Cool Climate Wine Summit · · 3 questions to check yourself

Slate is a fine-grained metamorphic rock, formed from compressed marine clay and split along a cleavage plane. In the Rhenish Massif, which carries the Mosel, the Saar, the Mittelrhein and the Ahr, it is the dominant vineyard soil, and in the steepest sites it is very nearly the only thing present.

What it does physically is uncontroversial. It is dark, so it absorbs heat during the day and releases it at night. It drains freely, which matters in a wet autumn. It is poor, so yields are naturally low. And it fractures, which lets roots get deep into ground that looks like rubble.

Blue, grey and red

The colours reflect the iron chemistry and the conditions the original sediment formed under. Red slate, weathered under oxidising conditions, is high in iron and comparatively rare; blue and grey slate are the common types.

Benedikt Nilles farms pure red slate with a high iron content, unusual on the Mosel, and describes what it gives: not the peach, banana or apricot you would expect, but something further forward, spicier and more herbal, with grapefruit as the citrus note and a flinty edge.

Marie Kirsten at Piesport works mainly on blue slate, which reads as deeper and more substantial, with a salty minerality. Stefanie Vornhecke works grey slate, which she says needs time for the minerality to work itself into the wine rather than sitting in your face.

“You can taste the rocks, you can taste the minerality, you can taste the steepness. That is my personal favourite vineyard.”

Daniel Immich, Weingut Immich-Anker · read the interview
Q1 What makes red slate different from blue and grey?
The colour is iron chemistry. Red slate is comparatively rare on the Mosel, which is part of why growers who have it talk about it.

The honest caveat

Whether slate itself can be tasted is genuinely contested. Minerals do not travel from rock to glass as flavour, and much of what is called minerality is understood as a product of acidity, low pH, sulphur compounds and winemaking.

Christina Andrae takes the honest position on the local phrase that a wine tastes as if you had licked the slate. She has licked the slate, and reports that it does not taste of minerality.

What is not contested is that the stone changes the vine. Heat, drainage, root depth and yield are all affected, and those do reach the glass. The disagreement is only about the mechanism.

Q2 What is the well-evidenced way slate affects a wine?
The physical effects on the vine are measurable. The direct transfer of mineral flavour is not, which is why careful growers describe the vine rather than the rock.

The reversal

Slate's greatest virtue is now a liability on the warmest sites. Stefanie Vornhecke has covered hers with low ground plants precisely because it no longer needs to store heat, and calls it switching off the underfloor heating.

Q3 Why would a Mosel grower deliberately cover bare slate?
The thermal advantage that made the region possible is now working against the style it is known for on the warmest slopes.

Sources

  1. Interview: Daniel Immich, Weingut Immich-Anker, Cool Climate Wine Summit Recorded by us. Quoted from the transcript.
  2. Deutsches Weininstitut, DWI
  3. Moselwein e.V., Moselwein
How this page was made. The background is standard viticultural reference material. The quotations come from interviews the Cool Climate Wine Summit recorded itself, and each one links to the full conversation. The text is drafted with AI assistance from those transcripts and then read, corrected and approved by a human editor before it is published. All interviews.
Newsletter

More of this, every few weeks

New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.

I am a