Why Good Cool Climate Wine Is Still Underpriced
Wine has become more expensive relative to income in most markets. What is actually driving the cost, and why the pressure is worst for the smallest producers.
Wine prices have risen faster than incomes in most European markets over the last decade, and the increase is largest at the bottom of the range where the customer is most price sensitive.
What is driving it
- Labour, which is the dominant cost in any hand-worked vineyard and has risen everywhere.
- Glass, which is energy intensive and rose sharply with energy prices.
- Energy in the cellar, for cooling, pressing and heating.
- Crop losses from frost, hail and disease, which raise the cost per bottle of what survives.
- Plant protection, particularly in wet years and particularly in organic programmes.
- Transport and packaging.
The steep slope problem
On flat ground machinery absorbs most of a labour cost increase. On a 70 per cent slope there is no machine, so a wage rise passes straight into the cost of the bottle.
Antoine de Mestral in Vaud states the outcome directly: prices are not high enough for the work involved, and he may go back to six hectares, or four. That is how vineyard area is lost, one grower at a time.
The squeeze
Costs are rising while consumption falls. That combination is severe for volume producers and manageable for anyone whose customers are drinking less and spending more, which is the pattern in the market.
It is also why Bob Molling's framing of sustainability keeps coming up in this series.
“Sustainability can only work if your company or your winery is sustainable as well. If you are running out of money, there will not be any sustainability anymore.”
Bob Molling, Molling Wines · read the interview
Sources
- Interview: Bob Molling, Molling Wines, Cool Climate Wine Summit Recorded by us. Quoted from the transcript.
- OIV, State of the World Vine and Wine Sector, OIV
- European Commission, wine sector, European Commission
More of this, every few weeks
New interviews, what the growers are seeing in the vineyard, and the deadlines that matter before the next Cool Climate Wine Summit. Three lists, so you only get the one you want.