The numbers at VDP. Weingut Kreuzberg in Dernau are easy to remember and harder to picture. Ten and a half hectares. Sixty-seven thousand bottles. Not one of them harvested by machine, because only a tenth of the estate lies flat enough for a tractor and buying one for that tenth is not worth it.

Watch the full interview

Benno Wagner, who makes the wine here, does not present that as heroism. He presents it as the arrangement the valley imposes, and as the thing that shapes the bottles more than any decision taken in the cellar.

The area makes the wines. The wine is not man made, the area is making the wine.

Benno Wagner, VDP. Weingut Kreuzberg

The Vet Who Did Not Finish

Asked the question every winemaker in this series gets, what he would do instead, Wagner gives the most unusual answer so far: veterinary science, which he studied in Budapest and never finished. He suspects his interest in nature comes from the same place.

He is not from the Ahr. He was born and raised in Munich and first came to Dernau in 2015, at 23 or 24, for an internship at this estate. Geisenheim followed until 2019, with a harvest in the Okanagan in Canada in 2017 and another in Valpolicella in 2018, making Amarone with Giuseppe Quintarelli. The person he names as his reference point is the estate's former winemaker, who took him on for that first internship and who today chairs the Norwegian growers' association. He still picks up the phone.

As a bottle he would be their Blanc de Noir, and the reasoning is more interesting than the choice: part of it spontaneously fermented and part not, part through malolactic and part not, part in oak and part not. Easy to drink, and not finished with the first sip.

Frühburgunder, Planted Where It Is Cool

The estate has existed since the mid 1950s and is in its fourth generation. Around 80 per cent of it is Spätburgunder and roughly 10 per cent Frühburgunder, the Pinot Madeleine, which almost nobody in Germany still grows in quantity. Everything ferments spontaneously. The reds go into 300 litre barrels rather than the standard 225, which is a deliberate choice: less surface against the volume, so less oak and less oxygen.

The first glass was the 2023 Frühburgunder, the entry level, ten months in used oak, 12 per cent alcohol. It arrives in the nose before you reach the glass, all freshness and lift, light red berries rather than the cherry of Pinot Noir, somewhere between raspberry and sour early summer strawberry, with the old wood adding a little smoke behind it.

Growing it is a fight. Thin skins, early ripening, and the first coloured grapes in the valley belong, as far as the birds and wasps are concerned, to the birds and wasps. In the cellar the skins are thinner than Pinot Noir but the extraction time is the same, which makes a structured Frühburgunder harder to build than a structured Pinot.

The answer is site selection, used against the grain. All three Frühburgunders sit in the cooler places: the entry level on the other side of the valley facing north, the Walporzheimer village wine on top of the hill where the slope eases, the GG in the Hardtberg above the famous Pfarrwingert. Put this grape on a warm Pinot Noir site, Wagner says, and it ripens three weeks early. Put it in the cool, and it takes its time.

If you can't change something, you shouldn't complain about it. You have to adapt to it.

Benno Wagner

Pinot Noir on Slate

The second wine was the 2022 Silberberg, a Grosses Gewächs from Ahrweiler and his own favourite of their GGs, because it is the one he considers typical. Eighteen to twenty months in barrel, around 30 per cent of it new, Burgundian 300 litre wood, medium toast. The oak is audible and never in front.

It is a structured wine with a backbone, warm in the fruit, plum and cherry with herbs behind them and the hibiscus note the Ahr often gives. The tannins are plentiful and the palate is where the wood does its work: espresso, smoke, cedar, a creamy edge from the malolactic. Set it beside their Sonnenberg, which grows on clay and comes out fuller and rounder, and the difference is the rock.

That comparison is Wagner's argument for the region. Slate is not rare in Germany, but the Mosel plants Riesling on it. Pinot Noir on slate is what the Ahr has, and in his view the reason its wines cannot be made anywhere else. The valley is tiny, 540 hectares, around a seventeenth of the Mosel, and geology changes along it: slate upstream where the valley is steep, loess, clay and greywacke where it widens, basalt further down.

Five Years

Asked where he would like the estate and the region to be in five years, Wagner does not talk about growth or new markets. He talks about 2021. He wants the valley back as it was before the flood: the construction sites gone, the tourists returning, people walking the vineyards and the villages and tasting the place without thinking first about what happened to it.

VDP. Weingut Kreuzberg pours at the Cool Climate Wine Summit in Copenhagen alongside other producers from the Ahr. The Frühburgunder is the rarer thing on the table and the one to ask for first.

Listen on Spotify