It was not a cool climate day in Warsaw. Wojciech Bońkowski MW opened the master class by pointing at the heat outside the room, which he called a good illustration of the subject, since several of the wines in front of us come from places that are moving out of the cool category and into something more dramatic. Six wines, fifty minutes, one region per glass, from the north of the Czech Republic to the Ahr.
What follows is the shape of that hour: the wines, the soils and the arguments. The wines are still worth looking for, and their producers pour at our fairs.
1. Bohemia: The Pinot Nobody Exports
The first glass came from a part of Europe most tasting rooms never see. Around 85 per cent of Czech wine comes from Moravia in the south, on the Austrian border. This wine came from the north, from Bohemia, where the two districts of Litoměřice and Mělník together hold under 700 hectares of vines. Traditionally white wine country for climatic reasons, with a red wine tradition that goes back to Emperor Charles IV.
The estate is Vinné sklepy Kutná Hora, founded around two decades ago on former Schwarzenberg land returned to the family after the war, and run today by a father and son. The wine is their top Pinot, Staré keře, which means old vines. Fifty years old, planted in the 1970s, which counts as ancient in a country where nearly everything was replanted for volume under socialism and again after 1991.
Soils are limestone, but an eroded, relatively fertile limestone mixed with river sand and marl, some way from the older stone of Burgundy. The wine has high acidity, a crunchy structure, fairly firm extraction and a little new oak. Bońkowski placed it close to the way Burgundy was made twenty years ago, on the edge of ripeness. None of it is exported: it sells in Prague and locally.
Both Burgundy and Czechia belonged to the Holy Roman Empire. It was perhaps not one country, but it was one culture.
Wojciech Bońkowski MW, on how Pinot travelled east2. Hessische Bergstraße: The Region You Forget
The least known of Germany's thirteen wine regions, 600 hectares, mostly tiny family estates selling at the door, historically three VDP members. It sits across the Rhine from Rheinhessen, and its peculiarity is that almost all the vineyards face west, which is rare in Germany, where south facing was the whole point for centuries of chasing ripeness.
Two things make it work anyway. The slopes are extraordinarily steep, steeper, Bońkowski suspects, than some of the Saar sites whose owners have been claiming the record for 25 years. And the soil is a black, mica rich granite that reflects sunlight and pushes ripeness further. The producer told him they get riper Pinot Noir here than in most of Baden, which is supposed to be Germany's warm room.
The wine is a village wine named after that soil, from Burgundy clones planted some thirty years ago, when almost nobody in Germany was planting French material. It carries a lot of new oak and carries it well, which led to the most practical piece of teaching in the hour: oak needs ripe fruit. Slightly underripe, leafy Pinot makes a perfectly good drink, but put it in new toasted barrels and you get a clash of personalities.
In good Burgundy, oak is part of the conversation. It is an instrument in the orchestra, but not the prima donna.
Wojciech Bońkowski MWAnd then the granite. Bońkowski made the disclaimer first, that minerality does not exist, that the vine absorbs nothing from the soil, that we have all heard the story. Then he made the case anyway: wines from metamorphic soils, and granite in particular, have a specific kind of acidity. He reached for northern Rhône Syrah as the comparison, that bitter cherry juiciness, and pointed out that Burgundians used to blend Syrah into their wines whenever the vintage was thin.
3. Nahe: Austerity as a Style
Spätburgunder is an afterthought in the Nahe, around 1.4 per cent of plantings in a region defined by Riesling. The Sinss family have been the exception, and Rudolf Sinss was one of the pioneers of the grape here. The wine was the Rosenberg Spätburgunder R, the top of three from that single vineyard, made in a slightly older Burgundian mould: close to two years in oak, a third of it new.
The site is sand from eroded limestone over a limestone base. That is the reason the family chose Pinot: Germany tends to want volcanic and metamorphic soils for its Riesling, and where there is limestone it plants Burgundian varieties instead. The Nahe is the most geologically varied region in the country, so both choices exist within a few kilometres of each other.
What came through in the glass was the region's character rather than the grape's. Nahe wines are vertical, fine and severe when young, the flight that Bońkowski says comes to kill you halfway through a day of tasting the Grosses Gewächs previews in Wiesbaden. He found northern Burgundy in it, Marsannay, and in the village wine something as sharp as Irancy.
The educational detail was at the producer's table, not in the room: three wines from the same vineyard and three different clonal selections, old German clones, new improved German clones, and the mostly Burgundian blend we were drinking. Taste them side by side and the phrase Burgundian style of Spätburgunder stops being marketing.
If you want to drive from the Nahe to Burgundy, do not speed in France. But it takes three and a half hours, so you can go for the weekend.
Wojciech Bońkowski MW4. Franken: No Oak, and a Plea for Silvaner
Franconia is administratively Bavaria, which is the fun fact for anyone teaching wine, and it has one of the oldest wine cultures in Germany, run for centuries by the Bishop of Würzburg rather than by a prince. The wine came from Wirsching in Iphofen, a family making wine since the 1600s and now in its fourteenth generation, and it was a village wine, an Ortswein, the middle tier of the VDP pyramid.
The soil is Keuper, which nobody can translate. Bońkowski built the definition from limestone: powdery compressed white stone, made of sea creatures, millions of years old. Keuper is a similar thing, hundreds of millions of years older, formed from land sediment rather than sea, greyish brown, low in calcium carbonate. Similar water retention, a cool stone, and a distinct spice in both the whites and the reds.
This was the only unoaked wine of the six, and the most obviously of its moment: light, chillable, fresh, driven by fruit rather than by tannin or acidity, the style German producers are now making for their own young market. His argument for it was commercial as much as aesthetic. If these wines are bought as alternatives to Burgundy, then an unoaked, light, fresh Pinot is precisely what Burgundy almost never sells, partly out of ambition and partly because of the price.
He also spent a minute campaigning. Silvaner has been in German vineyards for around 1,500 years, was the dominant grape at the start of the twentieth century, and survives in quantity only in Franken. Poland, he told the room, should plant Silvaner rather than putting Riesling and Pinot everywhere, because most of the sites being planted with them are not very good for either.
I want you to go home today having tasted Silvaner. It has been with us for 1,500 years, and it would be a pity if it disappeared.
Wojciech Bońkowski MW5 and 6. The Ahr: Slate, and the Steepest Work in the Room
The last two wines came from the same place, the Ahr, a small tributary of the Rhine between Koblenz and Bonn, further north than the Mosel and almost entirely given over to Spätburgunder across 700 to 800 hectares. The soil is blue Devonian slate, the same family of stone as the Mosel, and it works the same way: it holds heat, releases it in the evening and reflects light onto the fruit.
That combination is what Bońkowski says makes Ahr Pinot recognisable when he teaches blind tasting: a genuinely cool microclimate in a side valley with a short growing season, a fairly dry autumn that allows a long hang, and a soil that behaves like a radiator. Full ripeness and hard acidity in the same glass, which is a balance he does not find in Baden or the Pfalz.
The fifth wine came from Maibachfarm, founded in 1998, not a VDP member, with Alexander Weber as winemaker. The vineyard is Ahrweiler Rosenthal, terraced and very steep, and the wine is aged in French oak at yields below the four tonnes per hectare that Pinot already demands. Ripe cherry and plum fruit, little that is vegetal, fine tannins and, in his words, acidity like a steel spine.
The sixth was a Grosses Gewächs from Burggarten, admitted to the VDP in 2019, with Paul Schäfer as winemaker: blue slate again, with some greywacke, and 50 per cent new oak. The photograph of the vineyard drew a reaction from the room, tiny terraces on a slope that cannot be mechanised, Mosel and Saar levels of heroic viticulture.
The nose is like standing in the middle of a stone quarry. This wine is not really about fruit, like all great terroir wines.
Wojciech Bońkowski MW, on the last glassHis conclusion was about the difference between a good wine and a great site. Everybody in the flight, he said, is doing a good job with Pinot Noir, from Czechia through four German regions. But when a great terroir is in the glass you feel it, and in the last wine it was the tannins that gave it away: fine, crystalline, aligned, with no moment of dryness anywhere, under half a barrel of new oak that never got in the way.
The Cool Climate Pinot Noir Master Class was held at the Cool Climate Wine Summit in Warsaw in June 2026. Wojciech Bońkowski MW is a Master of Wine, a WSET educator and a writer based in Warsaw. The next master classes run in Copenhagen on 17 and 18 January 2027; the programme and registration are on the event pages.